Juggalos slam Insane Clown Posse for using AI over community artists when they can afford to do otherwise

Insane Clown Posse has sparked backlash from their devoted fanbase, known as juggalos, after releasing an AI-generated teaser video for their upcoming album “The Naught.” The controversy highlights growing tensions within music communities as artists increasingly turn to artificial intelligence for content creation, potentially alienating fans who value authentic artistic expression and want to support human creators within their communities.

What happened: Eagle-eyed juggalos identified telltale signs of AI generation in ICP’s album teaser, including garbled text frames and an hourglass with sand falling through what appears to be AI-generated imagery.

• The video also features a grandfather clock filled with nonsensical gears, exhibiting the “overly-smooth aura of AI that’s become unmistakable over the past few years.”
• While fans were excited about the long-awaited album ahead of the duo’s 25th annual Gathering of the Juggalos this summer, the AI content left many disappointed.

What fans are saying: Juggalos expressed frustration that ICP chose AI over hiring human artists, particularly given the duo’s financial resources and the talented artist community within their fanbase.

• “That AI clock looks dumb as f**k,” wrote one fan on X. “You have all the money in the world. Hire a real artist.”
• “WHACK!” responded Kevin Jones, labeled as a “top fan” on ICP’s Facebook page. “I was REALLY hoping that wasn’t the official design… Oh, well. Hopefully it still slaps.”
• “AI art is lame, when there’s many artists in the community that would be honored to be paid to draw amazing things,” wrote another fan.

The artist connection: Some criticism has focused on ICP’s increasing reliance on Tom Wood, a longtime fan who creates digital art for the duo and has embraced AI tools.

• “I try so hard but just can’t connect with Tom Wood’s style or this newer approach by ICP by going completely digital with their art,” commented one juggalo. “It’s just off-putting as f**k.”
• Wood’s social media posts show he’s “not afraid to dip his toes into the slop trough,” despite much of his earlier ICP work predating AI technology.

Broader AI adoption: ICP member Shaggy 2 Dope has increasingly embraced AI, previously battling an AI avatar of himself on his podcast “The Shaggy Show.”

• The official ICP X account has posted Studio Ghibli-style AI images of Shaggy as part of Gathering of the Juggalos promotions.
• “Kinda lame they used AI instead of one of the many talented jugg artists,” one fan responded to these posts.

Industry pattern: ICP joins other musical acts experimenting with AI for creating stylized imagery, reflecting a growing trend in the music industry.

• Wu-Tang Clan sparked similar controversy with a clearly AI-generated music video this year.
• Nick Cave, an Australian alternative rock frontman, initially criticized AI vocally before releasing his own AI-generated music video featuring Elvis Presley this week.
• In each case, comment sections reveal a divide between AI critics and fans who judge content on its own merits.

Fan reactions vary: While many juggalos criticized the AI usage, responses on Facebook show the community remains split.

• Comments range from astonishment at the technology’s capabilities to jokes about juggalo culture.
• Others continue traditional fan responses with simple expressions like “whoop whoop!”